Music/Germanys32 messages

Is er een wezenlijk verschil tussen Duitsland (10228 items) en West-Duitsland (17064 items) ?

Is there an essential difference between Germany (10228 items) and West Germany (17064 items) ?

No. BRD is BRD. Everything after 1989 is no longer West Germany, but nowadays we can filter that, so distinction is no longer necessary, I think.

There are also records from before 1949. Even in West Germany, which suggests that some importers have little historical awareness. Maybe you should add some aliases (Federal Republic, German Reich).

Er was een programaatje wat een keer in de zoveel  tijd draaide en die zetten alles keurig op W Duitsland wat verschenen was tussen 1949 en 1990.

Mits dat het jaartal vermeld is.

Helaas werkt dat niet meer? of wordt niet meer gebruikt.

Nee. BRD is BRD. Alles na 1989 is geen West-Duitsland meer, maar dat kunnen we tegenwoordig filteren dus onderscheid is niet meer noodzakelijk, denk ik.

Het is toch mooi om het in een oog opslag te zien.

There was a program that ran once in a while and they put everything neatly on W Germany that had appeared between 1949 and 1990.

Provided the year is stated.

Unfortunately that doesn't work anymore? or is no longer used.

No. BRD is BRD. Everything after 1989 is no longer West Germany, but we can now filter that so distinction is no longer necessary, I think.

It's nice to see it at a glance.

There are also records from before 1949. Even in West Germany, which suggests that some importers have little historical awareness. Maybe some aliases should be added (Federal Republic, German Reich).

I don't think is necessary, just use West Germany and East Germany during that period.

And historical awareness? are of course also occasional mistakes is not always clearly stated on the vinyl.

And not to forget they initially had something else on their mind to immediately West Germany to change in Germany on paper (so I think it took at least a year)?

At that time plates, model cars, etc. were brought onto the market and, for example, also Stamps

Die Briefmarken-Ausgaben aus der American- British Besatzungszone

And what about the postage stamps between 1945 and 1949? what do you call it?

I see that for Stamps there is a split between German Reich and Germany, Federal Republic [DEU] .

In other sections no distinction is made between Germany before and after the war. Not even with Coins or Banknotes.

The stamps between 1945 and 1949 can be found at Allied Occupation - Germany , (American and British zone) , (French zone) and (Russian zone) .

This is useful for stamps, because they are securities issued for regional use. For items such as records, such a subdivision does not seem very relevant to me.

It is indeed useful with records.

The quality of the cover and vinyl is often significantly less when it comes to releases in the formal Eastern block.

How many records were (do you estimate) released in Germany in the 4 years after the war?

How many records were (do you estimate) released in Germany in the 4 years after the war?

Very few due to a lack of shellac. This lasted until about 1948. As far as I am concerned, there is no need for "intermediate land" for 1945-1949. From 1911 (the first German 78 rpm record in Germany until 1949, everything is possible under Germany. From 1949 to 1989 under West Germany (FRG) and then again under Germany.

Dick does have a point. concerns East Germany (GDR) The quality of those plates is of a lower quality.

Where did the GDR suddenly come from? That's not FRG, is it?

No, that's not BRD. That is the former East Germany. Records were also released there. For Records and CDs, Germany appears 3 times in the country table: As Germany, as West Germany and as East Germany.

The discussion was about the difference between West Germany and Germany. For me, Germany consists of the combination of West and East Germany. Also for WW2.

Very little due to a lack of shellac. This lasted until about 1948. As far as I am concerned, there is no need for "intermediate land" for 1945-1949. From 1911 (the first German 78 rpm record in Germany until 1949, everything is possible under Germany. From 1949 to 1989 under West Germany (FRG) and then again under Germany.

I think that Frans has worded it correctly.

I keep finding it a strange choice, partly because that difference does not exist anywhere else in the catalog.

They really do get put together once, Peter. It only takes a lot of power, so you have to plan well.

Good news: I have already been able to 'book' a timeslot. Cow and horns, you know ...

Wiederwiedervereinigung ;-)

Wiedergutmachung! (;-)

Just to be clear .... what are you going to put together? Germany and West Germany?

Yip! That's what the question was about, wasn't it?

I assume that it would be better for us to do it immediately for the entire European Union, because nowadays 95% comes from, or is that a bridge too far?

It's always fun with you, Dick!

But seriously: this section was really the only anomaly within Catawiki as far as Germany is concerned. By the way, the merge is almost done. I just saw about 1500 items to go ...

Talk about anomaly. Are you going to merge all the German empires with the stamps?

I would rather see that effort is put into matters that have been waiting for a long time to be addressed.

What is your problem anyway?

That I don't see the point of merging and that the FRG is different from the whole of Germany.